Alma vs. Headway: Which Fits a Solo Therapy Practice?
Short answer: Headway and Alma both get you in network with insurance plans without credentialing each plan yourself; the difference is how they charge you. Headway has no membership fee but is adding a $9.99 fee to every session with a client who found you through its directory, while Alma charges a flat membership ($125 a month, or $95 a month billed annually, as of November 2026) and takes no cut of your private pay clients.
As a rough rule, Headway costs less if you bring most of your own clients, and Alma's flat fee can cost less if you'd rely on a platform's directory to fill a fuller caseload. Neither publishes the insurance rates it negotiates for you, so ask both for your actual rates, in writing, before you choose.
I used Headway myself when I was building my practice. I'd set my private pay fee at the low end of my local range, and I noticed that Aetna, through Headway, actually paid me more per session than my own fee. So I took Aetna through Headway and raised my private pay fee to match. About a year and a half in, I took a second maternity leave. I kept taking insurance so I could refill my caseload when I came back, and about two months after I returned, so many people were calling ready to pay privately that I stopped taking insurance. For me, a platform was a stepping stone, and a useful one.
Business education, not legal or financial advice. Both companies change their terms often; confirm current fees, rates, and contracts directly before signing.
The short version
- Both handle credentialing and billing with insurance plans, so you don't apply to each insurer yourself. Both require a full, independent license.
- Headway: no membership fee, paid twice a month, and, starting state by state from November 2026, a $9.99 fee per session with clients who found you on Headway.
- Alma: $125 a month, or $95 a month on an annual plan, plus more practice tools and community. No share of your private pay income. Now part of Spring Health.
- Pay rates vary by state, plan, session code, and license. Ask for yours in writing.
- Read the contract for who owns the client relationship, how you leave, and what happens to records.
In this guide
- Why therapists use insurance platforms
- Alma vs. Headway at a glance
- What Alma and Headway cost therapists
- Credentialing, pay, and tools
- Which one fits you
- Questions to ask before you sign
- Frequently asked questions
Why therapists use insurance platforms
Getting credentialed with insurance companies on your own commonly takes several months per plan, and then you handle claims, denials, and follow-up yourself. Platforms like Headway and Alma (and others such as Grow Therapy and Rula) contract with insurers as a group. You join the platform, it credentials you with its payer partners, bills the claims, and pays you.
The trade-off: you work within the platform's contracts, rates, and rules. For many new practices, that's worth it, because it gets you seeing insured clients in weeks instead of months. For some established practices, going direct pays more or gives more control. Our guide to credentialing with insurance companies covers going direct, and the cornerstone guide to starting a private practice shows where the insurance decision fits in the order of opening.
Alma vs. Headway at a glance
All details as of November 1, 2026, from each company's provider pages and help center, and from Choosing Therapy's October 2026 reviews.
| Headway | Alma | |
|---|---|---|
| Membership fee | None | $125 a month month-to-month, or $95 a month billed annually ($1,140 a year); sales tax may apply |
| Per-session fees | $9.99 per session with clients who found you on Headway's directory, rolling out by state from November 2026; none on clients you bring | None reported on insurance sessions |
| Private pay card fees | 2.95% on card payments; none on bank payments | 2.4% plus $0.30 per invoice on card payments |
| License required | Full, independent license in your state (PSYPACT alone doesn't count) | Full, independent license |
| Credentialing | 3 weeks to 4 months, depending on state and insurer | Under 45 days per payer, per Alma |
| When you're paid | Twice a month (15th and last day), even before the insurer pays Headway | Within about two weeks of each claim |
| Practice tools | Scheduling, notes, billing | Scheduling, notes, billing, plus a larger set of member tools, consultation, and community |
| Client directory | Yes | Yes |
| Insurance rates | Not published | Not published |
What Alma and Headway cost therapists
The real cost question used to be simple: Headway is free, Alma isn't. That changed in 2026. Now the answer depends on where your platform clients come from.
Headway's new marketplace fee. Headway's help center says the $9.99 fee applies to every session with a client who found you through Headway's directory, for as long as you see them, including private pay sessions with that client. It doesn't apply to clients you add yourself, clients who book through your own booking link, clients who found you on Headway before the change, health system referrals, or no-shows. Headway says each state gets at least 7 days' notice by email and in-app banner, with all states covered by the end of 2026.
Alma's membership. Alma's fee is fixed, so it costs the same whether you see 3 clients a week or 20. At $95 a month on the annual plan, that's $1,140 a year.
Here's how the math works out over a year, using 48 working weeks. These are illustrations, not quotes.
| Platform sessions a week | Headway, all clients bring themselves | Headway, all clients from its directory | Alma, annual plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | $0 | About $1,440 a year | $1,140 a year (about $7.90 a session) |
| 8 | $0 | About $3,840 a year | $1,140 a year (about $3 a session) |
| 15 | $0 | About $7,190 a year | $1,140 a year (about $1.60 a session) |
Most therapists land somewhere in between: some clients from the platform's directory, some from their own website, Google profile, and referrals. That's one reason being findable on your own matters even if you take insurance. Clients who find you directly and book through your link don't carry Headway's fee.
Fees are only half the picture. A platform that pays $10 more per session for your main plan can easily outweigh a membership. Use the fee calculator to compare what you'd keep each way once you have real rates.
Credentialing, pay, and tools
Credentialing. Both handle the paperwork. You'll still need your license, an NPI, malpractice insurance, and often a CAQH profile. Headway's help center gives 3 weeks to 4 months depending on the state and insurer, and notes that insurers can take up to 8 more weeks to load you into their systems. Alma says under 45 days per payer. Get an estimate for your state in writing, and ask whether you can see clients before every plan is active. Our liability insurance guide covers the malpractice coverage both require.
Pay. This is where most therapists decide, and where information is weakest. Neither platform publishes its rates, and self-reported figures online vary widely. Rates can also change after you join: in 2026, Aetna told Alma clinicians it would pay 53-minute-plus sessions (90837) at the same rate as shorter 90834 sessions, and pay doctoral-level clinicians at the master's rate for some codes, effective July 15 (reported by Behavioral Health Business, May 2026). My own experience was that a platform's rate for one plan beat my early private pay fee, which is exactly why it's worth asking.
Ownership. Spring Health, an employer mental health company, completed its acquisition of Alma on May 1, 2026, and Alma now operates as part of Spring Health. Alma says nothing changes day to day for providers, but it's worth watching how terms evolve.
Tools. Both include scheduling, notes, and billing, so many therapists don't need a separate EHR for platform clients. If you also see private pay clients outside the platform, decide whether you want one system or two. Two systems means two places for records, which matters for HIPAA and for your own sanity. Our guide to practice management systems compares the options.
Relationship and leaving. Read what happens to your clients if you leave, whether there are non-solicitation terms, and how you get your records out.
Which one fits you
| Your situation | Often a better fit |
|---|---|
| Opening your practice, mostly bringing your own clients | Headway (no fixed cost, no fee on clients you bring) |
| Counting on a platform's directory to fill a fuller caseload | Compare both; Alma's flat fee may cost less than Headway's per-session fee |
| Mostly private pay, a few insurance clients | Headway, or going direct with one plan |
| You want consultation, community, and more tools in one place | Alma |
| You're pre-licensed or an associate | Neither accepts you yet; both require full, independent licensure |
| You want the highest possible rate long-term | Compare platform rates with going direct |
Many therapists use a platform while the caseload builds, then shift toward private pay or direct contracts. That's what I did.
How Well Launched helps: Well Launched walks you through the insurance decision in order: private pay, a platform, going direct, or a mix, with what each means for your fee, paperwork, and timeline for your license and state. The fee calculator compares what you'd earn each way, so you choose with real numbers instead of forum guesses. The free checklist shows where this decision fits in your opening plan.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What will I be paid per session, by plan and session code (for example, 90791, 90834, and 90837), in my state?
- How long will credentialing take for each plan, and can I see clients before it's done?
- When and how am I paid, and what happens with denied or reprocessed claims?
- What fees apply beyond the membership, and, for Headway, which of my clients would carry the marketplace fee?
- Can I keep seeing private pay clients outside the platform?
- If I leave, what happens to my clients, my records, and my insurance contracts?
- Is there a minimum caseload or availability requirement?
Frequently asked questions
Is Headway still free for therapists?
Mostly, but not entirely. Headway has no membership fee, but starting state by state from November 2026 it deducts $9.99 from each session with a client who found you through its directory. Clients you add yourself or who book through your own link don't carry the fee.
How much does Alma cost for therapists?
$125 a month on a monthly plan, or $95 a month billed annually ($1,140 a year), as of November 2026. Sales tax may apply, and Alma sometimes runs first-year promotions. Alma doesn't take a share of your private pay income.
Does Alma or Headway pay more?
It depends on your state, license, plans, and session codes. Neither publishes its rates, and self-reported figures vary. Ask both for your rates in writing, then compare what you'd keep after fees.
Can associates or pre-licensed therapists join Alma or Headway?
No. Both require a full, independent license in the state where you practice. Headway also says PSYPACT authority alone doesn't qualify you. Pre-licensed clinicians usually see insured clients through a group practice instead.
How long does Headway credentialing take?
Headway's help center says 3 weeks to 4 months, depending on the state and insurer, and insurers can take up to 8 more weeks to add you to their systems. Alma says under 45 days per payer.
Do I need my own EHR if I use Headway or Alma?
Not for platform clients, since both include scheduling, notes, and billing. If you also see private pay clients outside the platform, you'll need a system for them too.
Sources
- Headway Help Center, "Understanding the marketplace service fee" (checked November 1, 2026, via Klarity's October 2026 summary)
- Choosing Therapy, Headway for therapists review (updated October 27, 2026)
- Choosing Therapy, Alma for therapists review (updated October 19, 2026)
- Alma, membership benefits for mental health providers (checked November 1, 2026)
- Klarity, "Marketplace session fees in 2026: Headway's $9.99 fee" (October 8, 2026)
- Behavioral Health Business, "Aetna cuts rates with Alma-contracted therapists" (May 21, 2026)
- Spring Health, "Spring Health joins forces with Alma"
Decide insurance with real numbers
The free checklist walks you through private pay, insurance, and platforms in the right order for your license and state. Blueprint and Launch add the fee calculator and your paperwork.
Related: Credentialing with insurance companies · How much should I charge for therapy? · How much do therapists make?
Photo by Jens Lelie on Unsplash
Free tools: therapy fee calculator · startup cost calculator · rules by state · Psychology Today counter