
Short answer: taking insurance usually brings clients sooner but sets your rate and adds claims work, while private pay lets you set your fee and get paid at the session but depends on people finding you and choosing to pay. Neither is better in general; the right choice depends on your local market, your specialty, how fast you need a full caseload, and how much billing work you're willing to carry.
Many therapists start with a mix and change it as they grow. About two thirds of therapists on Psychology Today accept insurance, according to a 2024 study of more than 175,000 listings, so both paths are common.
I'm a licensed psychologist with a full practice in Austin, and I don't take insurance today. But I did take it early on. My path is below, along with the public numbers that help you compare.
Business education, not legal, billing, or tax advice. Insurance contracts, Medicare rules, and state laws vary, so confirm the details with each insurer, your Medicare contractor, and your licensing board. Sources below were checked November 6, 2026.
The short version
- Insurance trades rate for reach. Many clients search by plan, so being in network can fill a caseload faster. In exchange, each insurer sets what you're paid, and you handle claims, denials, and waiting to be paid.
- Private pay trades reach for control. You set your fee, get paid at the session, and keep a lighter admin load. In exchange, you have to be findable, and some clients can't afford your full fee.
- Out of network is a middle path. Private pay clients with out-of-network benefits can submit a superbill to their insurer and may get part of your fee back.
- Rules still apply to private pay. Self-pay clients get a Good Faith Estimate under the No Surprises Act, and Medicare clients can't simply pay you privately unless you've formally opted out.
- A mix is normal. Many therapists open private pay while credentialing runs, keep one or two panels, and drop them later.
In this guide
- Insurance vs. private pay: the tradeoffs side by side
- What insurance and private pay actually pay
- How out-of-network benefits and superbills work
- The rules that apply either way
- How I decided, and why I changed
- How to decide for your practice
- Can you switch from insurance to private pay later?
- Frequently asked questions
Insurance vs. private pay: the tradeoffs side by side
Here's how the two models compare on the things that shape your week.
| In network with insurance | Private pay (with superbills) | A mix | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who sets your rate | Each insurer, in your contract | You | Both |
| What the client pays you | A copay, coinsurance, or deductible amount | Your full fee | Depends on the client |
| When you're paid | After the claim is processed, often weeks later | At the session | Both |
| Admin work | Claims, eligibility checks, authorizations for some plans, denials, audits | Card on file, monthly superbills, Good Faith Estimates | Both sets |
| Time before you can start | After credentialing, which often takes months per insurer | Right after your setup is done | Start private pay while credentialing finishes |
| How clients find you | Insurer directories, plus clients searching by plan | Your website, Google, directories, referrals | Both |
| Diagnosis needed | Yes, for every claim | Only if the client wants a superbill | Depends |
| Who you can serve | Clients who can afford a copay | Clients who can afford your fee, plus any reduced-fee spots | Wider range |
Every insurance claim carries a diagnosis code, and some clients choose private pay partly for that reason. Credentialing is also slow; our guide to credentialing with insurance companies covers the steps and timelines, so start early and see private pay clients in the meantime.
What insurance and private pay actually pay
Commercial insurers don't publish their therapy rates, but public benchmarks show the range.
| Benchmark | Amount | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Average private pay fee, all therapists | About $143 a session | Psychology Today listings, late 2023 (Zhu et al., 2024) |
| Private pay fee, therapists who don't take insurance | About $156 | Same study |
| Private pay fee, therapists who also take insurance | About $141 | Same study |
| Psychologists who don't take insurance | About $196 | Same study, vs. about $168 for psychologists who do |
| Medicaid, 45-minute session (CPT 90834) | About $83, state average | Same study, 2022 fee schedules |
| Medicare 2026, 45-minute session (CPT 90834) | $113.90 national | Non-facility, before local adjustment |
| Medicare 2026, 60-minute session (CPT 90837) | $167.01 national | Non-facility, before local adjustment |
| Medicare for LMFTs and LMHCs | 75% of the psychologist amount | CMS |
Cash fees averaged roughly 40% more than Medicaid rates in the Zhu study, and the gap between therapists who do and don't take insurance was biggest for psychologists. Medicare's fee schedule is a useful public reference point, though commercial plans can pay above or below it. CMS says Medicare pays marriage and family therapists and mental health counselors 75% of what it pays a clinical psychologist.
The rate isn't the whole picture. To compare fairly, look at what you keep per hour of your time:
- Insurance: the contracted rate, minus billing or platform fees, claims time, and denied sessions.
- Private pay: your fee, minus card processing, marketing time, and any reduced-fee spots.
Then ask how many sessions each path will realistically fill near you. The free therapy fee calculator lets you enter an insurance rate alongside your private pay fee, so you can compare the take-home of each. Our guide on how much to charge for therapy walks through setting the fee itself.
How out-of-network benefits and superbills work
"Out of network" means you aren't contracted with the client's insurer. The client pays you your full fee, and then, if their plan has out-of-network benefits, they ask the insurer to reimburse part of it.
- You charge your fee at the session.
- You give a superbill, usually once a month. It's a detailed receipt with what insurers need: your name, license, NPI, and tax ID; the client's information; session dates; CPT service codes; the diagnosis code; and the amount paid.
- The client submits it to their insurer.
- The insurer reimburses the client under their plan's out-of-network terms, often after a deductible is met.
Plans differ a lot. Some PPO plans have out-of-network benefits; many HMO and EPO plans have none. Encourage clients to ask their insurer about their out-of-network deductible and what percentage the plan pays, and don't promise what they'll get back.
The superbill shows what the client actually paid, including a reduced fee (our sliding scale guide explains why). You'll need an NPI for it even if you never bill insurance, and most practice management systems generate superbills for you.
The rules that apply either way
Private pay doesn't mean rule-free. Two federal rules matter most, plus your state's.
Good Faith Estimates. Under the No Surprises Act, clients who are uninsured or who choose not to have a claim submitted to their insurance are "uninsured or self-pay individuals." That includes private pay clients who plan to submit superbills on their own. The federal rule requires a Good Faith Estimate within 1 business day of scheduling a service that's at least 3 business days away, within 3 business days of scheduling a service 10 or more business days away, and within 3 business days of a request. Our Good Faith Estimate guide has a template. If you're fully in network, you mostly won't give them, except to clients who choose to pay out of pocket.
Medicare. Psychologists, clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, and mental health counselors are all on Medicare's list of practitioners who may opt out. Opting out is how you see Medicare beneficiaries for a private fee: you file an affidavit with your Medicare contractor, the opt-out lasts 2 years, and you sign a written private contract with each Medicare client before services begin, in which they agree to pay you and not submit claims. The timing rules are strict, so read them closely or ask a Medicare billing professional before you see your first Medicare client privately.
Your state. Some states have their own rules on billing, fee disclosure, or surprise billing. Check what applies to your license in our private practice rules by state, each linked to the official source.
HSA money. The IRS lists amounts paid to a psychologist and for psychiatric care as medical expenses, and HSA funds can pay for medical care as the tax code defines it (Publication 969).
How I decided, and why I changed
When I opened, I set my fee at the low end of the local range. Aetna through Headway paid me more per session than my own private pay fee, so I took it, and I raised my private pay fee to match.
About a year and a half in, I took a second maternity leave. I kept taking insurance so I could refill my caseload when I came back. About two months after I returned, I was getting steady calls from people ready to pay privately, so I stopped taking insurance. Today my practice is fully private pay: clients pay at the session, and I give them a superbill.
These days, in my last four months, all but two new inquiries found me on Google or ChatGPT. For a private pay practice, being findable does the work an insurance directory does for an in-network one. If you're curious about platforms like the one I used, see Alma vs. Headway and Headway's new per-session fee.
How to decide for your practice
There's no score; look at which way most of your answers lean.
Insurance may fit if:
- [ ] You need a full caseload soon and don't yet have a referral network or website traffic
- [ ] Most people in your area use one or two large plans, and those plans pay a rate you can live on
- [ ] You want to serve clients who couldn't pay your full fee
- [ ] You're comfortable with diagnosis codes, claims, and some waiting to be paid
Private pay may fit if:
- [ ] Local private pay fees (or your specialty) are well above what insurers pay near you
- [ ] You have, or are building, ways for people to find you directly: a website, a Google profile, a directory profile, referral relationships
- [ ] You want to set your own fee and session length
- [ ] You can offer a few reduced-fee spots for people who can't afford the full fee
A mix may fit if you checked items on both lists. A common version: open private pay right away, start credentialing with one or two plans that pay well in your area, and revisit the mix once a year.
The free checklist puts this decision early in your opening plan, because it changes your fee, your paperwork, and your timeline.
How Well Launched helps: This decision touches your fee, your paperwork, and how people will find you, and those pieces have to match. Well Launched's plan puts the payment decision in the right spot for your license and state, then walks you through your fee, your paperwork, and your directory and Google profiles, most steps about 10 minutes each. If you go private pay, Launch also designs, builds, and hosts the website people find you through.
Can you switch from insurance to private pay later?
Yes, and many therapists do, though it takes planning.
- Read your contracts. Check each insurer contract for the notice you must give before leaving the network and any terms about continuing care for current clients. Follow the contract, not general advice.
- Give clients notice. Tell current clients early, explain their options (paying privately, using out-of-network benefits, or a referral to an in-network clinician), and help anyone who wants to transfer.
- Drop one plan at a time if you're unsure.
- Be findable first. Leaving a network removes you from its directory. Build up the ways people find you directly before you leave.
Our guide on how to get therapy clients covers those channels, and the Psychology Today profile tips explain how to describe your fees and superbills.
Frequently asked questions
Do therapists make more money with private pay or insurance?
It depends on your market. Private pay fees are often higher than insurance rates, and in a 2024 study therapists who didn't take insurance charged about $156 on average versus about $141 for those who did. But a full insurance caseload can bring in more than a half-empty private pay one.
What percentage of therapists don't take insurance?
About one in three. A 2024 study of 175,083 therapists listed on Psychology Today found that 64.9% accepted insurance. Psychologists accepted it less often than master's-level clinicians.
Can I take insurance and private pay clients at the same time?
Yes. Many practices do. Read each insurer contract to see whether it lets you see that plan's members as private pay clients, and for Medicare clients, you'd need to formally opt out to charge them privately.
Do private pay clients need a Good Faith Estimate?
Yes. Clients who are uninsured or who choose not to have a claim submitted to insurance count as self-pay under the No Surprises Act, and that includes clients who submit their own superbills.
What is a superbill?
A superbill is a detailed receipt a private pay client can send to their insurer for out-of-network reimbursement. It lists your NPI and license, session dates, service and diagnosis codes, and what was paid.
Can I stop taking insurance once my practice is full?
Yes. Give the notice your insurer contracts require, tell current clients early, and offer referrals to anyone who needs an in-network clinician.
Sources
- Zhu et al., "Insurance acceptance and cash pay rates for psychotherapy in the US," Health Affairs Scholar, September 2024 (175,083 therapists on Psychology Today) (checked November 6, 2026)
- Medicare 2026 national payment for CPT 90834 (third-party, from CMS data) and CPT 90837 (checked November 6, 2026)
- CMS, Marriage and Family Therapists and Mental Health Counselors (75% payment rate) (checked November 6, 2026)
- 45 CFR 149.610, Good Faith Estimates for uninsured or self-pay individuals (Cornell LII) (checked November 6, 2026)
- 42 CFR 405.400, Medicare opt-out definitions (Cornell LII), 405.410, conditions for opting out, and 405.415, private contract requirements (checked November 6, 2026)
- IRS Publication 502, Medical and Dental Expenses and Publication 969, Health Savings Accounts and Other Tax-Favored Health Plans (checked November 6, 2026)
Decide early, then build around it
The free checklist puts your insurance decision in the right order for your license and state, along with your fee, paperwork, and profiles. Want help with the whole setup, website included? See the plans.
Related: How to start a private practice as a therapist · Credentialing with insurance companies · How much should I charge for therapy?
Photo by Money Knack on Unsplash
Free tools: therapy fee calculator · startup cost calculator · rules by state · Psychology Today counter
Start a private practice, by license: Counselor (LPC, LMHC, LCPC, LPCC) · LMFT · LCSW · psychologist · associate